When I wrote about ASD Essentials three days after it launched, most of us had read the chapters and not much else. A month later I have been through the assessment workbook, and the industry has had time to react. This post covers both.
What the industry is saying
Most people think the change was due. ASD says the consultation response was overwhelmingly positive, according to Australian Cyber Security Centre head Stephanie Crowe in iTnews. The Australian Computer Society called the new guidance overdue. I have not found a serious voice arguing to keep the maturity ladder.
The main worry is who does the judging. The Essential Eight could be checked against a list. ASD Essentials asks an assessor to judge whether a control works. ACS chief executive Dr Prins Ralston put it this way in Information Age: "Now the question is whether your security actually works." His concern is that nobody has yet set a standard for the people answering it, and that boards could be handed "fully effective" ratings that no one can stand behind. The same article notes that the government's registered assessor program has a little over 400 assessors, who mostly work with government and large business.
Smaller businesses feel left out. ASD wrote the series mainly for Commonwealth entities, critical infrastructure and large organisations. Information Age's summary was that it offers little for small and medium businesses. ASD's answer is a separate small business handbook built on four actions: multi-factor authentication, fast updates, regular backups and staff training. Several IT providers have made the practical point that most mid-sized businesses have no security lead, and the IT manager already has a full-time job.
The documents do not always agree with each other. Perth consultancy VibeZero read all 18 documents in the release and found places where the PDF and web versions of the same action are worded differently, with no statement from ASD on which one prevails. Their advice is sound: record which version you assessed against.
There is still no date. ASD has set no deadline and no mandate. Contracts, insurers and regulators that ask for an Essential Eight maturity level still mean it.
What we now know about scoring
ASD published an assessment workbook for the enterprise IT chapter. It answers the question my first post could not: how do you get rated?
- The chapter has 28 principles and 58 actions.
- Each action is rated in each domain it applies to: not assessed, not effective, partially effective or fully effective.
- A principle takes the rating of its weakest action. One gap pulls the whole principle down.
- Each domain gets a percentage. A fully effective principle counts as one, a partially effective principle counts as half, and a not effective principle counts as nothing.
- For every action, ASD lists what an assessor would expect to see at each rating. These indicators are a guide for the assessor, not a checklist.
- The workbook has a sheet where you enter your Essential Eight maturity level. It then shows which of your existing controls count as evidence under each new action. This is the most practical way I have seen to find out how much of your work carries over.
Brisbane consultant Greg Tereszczyn counted the evidence guide and found that 23 of the 58 actions have no Essential Eight control behind them (TERESEC). That matches what I see in the workbook. The new work sits mostly in governance, suppliers, training, network zoning, content filtering and detection.
Five requirements that will catch Essential Eight organisations out
These come from the indicators in ASD's workbook.
- SMS and push MFA rate as not effective. ASD asks for phishing-resistant MFA. Its indicators list SMS, voice and push-only methods under "not effective". For many organisations this is the single biggest gap.
- There are no fixed patching deadlines in the chapter. The Essential Eight set windows such as 48 hours. ASD Essentials asks you to define risk-based timeframes and then meet them consistently. Timeframes set by a regulator or contract still apply.
- Admin work needs its own environment. A separate admin account on an everyday laptop is not enough. ASD expects administration from dedicated, hardened environments kept apart from email and web browsing.
- Backups must be out of reach of production. If a compromised production account can reach the backups, they rate as not effective. Restores also have to be tested against your recovery targets.
- Someone senior must own AI. A named executive is expected to be accountable for how the organisation uses AI, including AI built into software you buy.
One more point for businesses whose IT is run by a provider. ASD says outsourcing a service does not transfer accountability for its security outcomes. A domain is not effective just because someone else has been given the job.
Where to start
If you run your own systems, start with the two Phase 1 areas ASD names: internet-facing systems and identity services. Then look at who is accountable at the top.
We have updated our free quick check to cover this. It now asks one question about your organisation, then gives you either sixteen questions on the Essential Eight or twelve drawn from ASD Essentials. It takes about five minutes and shows which area to work on first.
If an insurer or customer still asks you for a maturity level, an Essential Eight assessment remains the right tool. We map the result to the ASD Essentials domains so the same work serves both.
Frequently asked questions
Has anything changed since ASD Essentials launched? The framework has not changed. What has changed is how well it is understood. The assessment workbook shows how ratings are worked out, and the industry has started to point out where the hard parts are.
Is ASD Essentials mandatory now? No. ASD has set no deadline. Keep meeting any obligation that names the Essential Eight.
Does SMS-based MFA still count? It still counts toward an Essential Eight obligation that accepts it. Under ASD Essentials, the workbook's indicators rate SMS, voice and push-only MFA as not effective.
Can a small business use ASD Essentials? Yes. ASD says the outcomes matter just as much for smaller organisations, though the series is written for larger ones. ASD also publishes a separate small business handbook.
Ben Jones is Cyber Security Practice Lead at Coder Trove.